we're buddies. we're real good buddies.

people review stuff

Sunday, December 10, 2006

An Inconvenient Truth (2006)

[I sent this last week to the wrong e-mail address. So now you're
getting a two-fer from me.]

Too much personal Al Gore stuff. While I have nothing against the guy
(and, given his obvious commitment to the issue, I would be happy if
he somehow found his way to the presidency as a result of it),
transitioning back and forth from glacier before-and-after pictures to
the speaker's childhood on a ranch is jarring and distracting, and
dilutes the focus of the film. Instead of being a sobering, objective
look at the environment's trajectory, it takes on the flavor of a
campaign stump speech.

My opinion of "saving" the environment was shaped by, of all things,
Jurassic Park (the novel, not the film). I couldn't quote it
directly to save my life, but the scientist Ian Malcolm expresses his
belief that the situation should be re-framed, not as a race to save
"nature" or the environment, but a race to save the future of human
life. "Nature," in one form of life or another, will survive whatever
we do to screw up the climate, An asteroid striking the Earth didn't
end life, although it did drastically alter the climate and end the
dinosaurs. So with everything we're doing that's wrong right now,
we're only hurting ourselves; the fatalistic question is whether
people care enough about the future of people to act now. We all know
we should care, but do we?

Also, if we blow it and humans all die, who's gonna take over in 65
million years? Anyone see A Sound of Thunder? Giant
gorilla-lizards would be awesome.

2 Comments:

  • At 8:21 PM, Blogger Chris said…

    Yeah, even the neo-liberals have caught up to this. The Economist just said that we should do something about global warming because it'll cost us more money if we wait and everyone in south india dies than it will if we do commit about 1% of global production to working on it. so there you go, those guys know what they are talking about.

    for another take on this see: http://razetheladder.blogspot.com/2006/12/al-gore-left-something-out.html

     
  • At 8:22 PM, Blogger Chris said…

    whoops. try this:
    link

     

Post a Comment

<< Home